You’ve been a fan of [insert your favorite franchise] since the age of 7, and now you’re actually in the room with someone who wants you to help write the next iteration. So what do you say? For writers asked to take their shot at an IP pitch, Dalan Musson (Street Fighter, Captain America: Brave New World) has some suggestions.
Dalan Musson. Photo by Abigail-Welkom.
Question: I’m being brought in to meet on a big IP project. How do I make my take stand out while still staying true to the foundation of the source material?
First and foremost: congratulations. Seriously. Being in the conversation, getting in the room, is a big step. Regardless of how this particular one shakes out, I remind everyone (including myself) that every meeting, every pitch, is investing in a potential future job. Maybe you don’t get this one because the director wants to hire his cousin (happened to me); maybe you don’t get that one because the star of the movie gets into a fistfight with the executive in charge (also happened to me; yes, really). But if you show well, if they like you, if you come in like a pro with good ideas and a good attitude and give them your best—regardless of outcome—they’ll remember. And they’ll bring you back…and maybe next time is your time.
When a piece of IP gets brought to me and I’m deciding how to formulate an approach, I ask myself a series of questions. The first (and probably most important) one being, “Am I a fan?”
And that’s not, “Did I grow up obsessed with this property and do I have deeply ingrained nostalgia for the original?” Because if that was the case, you’d only ever be able to tackle what, two or three properties, lifetime? Make no mistake: it’s very helpful if this is your dream project and you’ve already spent some of your more awkward/formative years writing fan fiction on tumblr or AO3. But that’s not always the case. You don’t need to have read every novel or played every game.
The “note behind the note” here is actually, “Can you identify what it is about the property that makes this special?” Is it the sprawling world? Is it the constantly evolving romantic relationships between the ensemble cast of main characters? Is it the technology, the core conflict at the heart of the first three books, the art style of the graphic novel mixed with the spare, philosophical dialogue?
Find that core. Start there, and build. If the world is what people really gush over, look for the most compelling characters who could live in and interact with that world. And those characters don’t have to be drawn directly from the source material. If we use Andor as an example: many of the most layered, nuanced, and interesting characters are original to the show…but they still feel like they “belong” in the world of Star Wars.

“I don’t necessarily subscribe to the ‘tell a personal story about your connection to the source material’ advice when it comes to pitching a take. But it is important for them to know what makes you stand out.”
I also make sure to ask myself, “Why does this need to be adapted from (comic/video game/novel) to (feature/TV/back to a video game/whatever)?” Because let’s remember, each medium serves its material in a different way. You can’t capture internal monologues in a movie the same way you can in a novel; you can’t control the narrative in a game the same way you can a movie. When adapting a property from one medium to another, find how you can take advantage of the strengths of the target medium, and what will give the adaptation a reason to exist. Simply taking the narrative beats of a video game and pitching them in a three-act format likely leaves a lot of creative meat on the bone, and certainly isn’t going to separate you from the pack.
To that end, my favorite exercise when I’m sitting down and blue-skying is to find and think about the moments and scenes that aren’t “on the page” in the original. This is a chance to fill in the blanks, to tell the story of how the characters got to where we’ve already seen them, or experience and explore the events they’ve referred to in seemingly throwaway moments.
As I’m putting those moments together (hopefully in an order that makes some kind of sense), I make sure to remind myself, “What are the core tenets of the property that absolutely, positively, cannot be violated?” As much as I might want to veer hard left and go wayyyy off the beaten path, I remind myself that somewhere down the chain of rights-holders, someone I pitch to is going to make an unpleasant face if something I come up with requires a wholesale reimagining of everything the property is built on. If you sit down (or log in to Zoom, I guess) and the first words out of your mouth are, “Okay. Harry Potter… but there’s no magic!”, then boy oh boy, you better follow up with something absolutely undeniable. There are always going to be some bumpers on your bowling lane…but there’s plenty of opportunity to create something amazing within those confines.
And finally, here’s the big one: “Why you?”
I don’t necessarily subscribe to the “tell a personal story about your connection to the source material” advice when it comes to pitching a take. But it is important for them to know what makes you stand out. It could be a childhood connection to the material, but it could also be the fact that you drilled down on the one thing—the one element of a single character—that is the heart and soul, the secret owner, of the property. And if you can convince them that taking that element and building it out is the key to success? Buddy, you might just be the right person for the job.
(Note: the WGAW encourages writers to use the Project Page to gather key information, including how many other writers are competing, whether the IP rights have been secured, and what other talent is attached.)